Premier League fail in attempt against Everton as £4.9m decision made

Everton will not have to foot the entirety of the £4.9million bill in legal costs for last season’s Profitability and Sustainability Rules case, according to the Times.

The newspaper reported via its online edition on 4 September, that the Toffees will only be asked to pay a third of the total amount.

The remaining £3.2million that led to the club being docked ten points will be borne by the Premier League.

Everton may feel they should not be paying anything given how flawed the Premier League’s rules are

The Toffees have every right to feel that they should not bear any costs for this case as it stems from their argument regarding the inherent flaws within the Premier League’s regulations.

The club might argue that the ambiguity in the rules, which allowed for interpretations leading to their initial points deduction, reflects poorly on the clarity and fairness of the league’s governance.

Everton could assert that these regulatory shortcomings misled them, suggesting that any financial penalty or legal cost should be waived due to the Premier League’s own regulatory oversights.

This perspective would highlight the need for the Premier League to bear full responsibility for costs, given the rules’ lack of precision, which arguably led to an unfair disadvantage for the club, affecting their competitive standing and financial implications unfairly due to inadequacies in the league’s legal framework.

The fight with the Premier League continues and it remains to be seen how many other sides are targeted by the league like the Toffees were.

In other Everton news, the club are in deep trouble with their takeover bid as a Bramley-Moore Dock claim has emerged.

For more Everton news, follow us on Facebook or join our brand new WhatsApp Channel for instant updates to be sent straight to your phone